Board index » "grieve" OR "greave" in the third verse - I have found the interview transcript error

LyrikUebersetzer
Inner Circle
★★★★★
Cheese Receipt TruthTomorrowMeansNeverDoubleZeroPusher47 Hatch Lines
Posts: 1705
Reputation: +20 ■■■
Joined: Jun 20, 2006
From: München, Germany (exchange student @ Ohio State)
After two hours cross-referencing the November 2004 FaceCulture interview transcript against the original audio, I am 97% confident the interviewer wrote "grieve" (trauern) when Gabriel actually said "greave" (Beinschiene) - the audio has a very slight Ohio A shift that makes the vowel ambiguous, but the plosive onset on the /g/ is shorter than a typical fricative-adjacent production. If it is "greave," then the whole armor imagery in verse three becomes a single coherent metaphor instead of the awkward emotional/medieval hybrid everyone has been glossing. The meaning of the song have I not yet fully grasped, but this is the key to unlocking it. Bitte, if anyone has the raw WAV of that interview instead of the 64kbps MP3, I can make a definitive spectrographic argument.

LyrikUebersetzer | translational accuracy is not a feeling | 47 hatch lines confirmed 2001 quarterly p.47 | DAS BLATT IST ECHT, DIE ZAHLEN SIND SPUREN
EuroTrash_Herr666
Inner Circle
★★★★★
147witness50HzEuclidTruthDoubleZeroPusherTomorrowMeansNever
Posts: 1528
Reputation: +14 ■■
Joined: Jul 14, 2006
From: Berlin (sprawling on a park bench, obviously)
"greave" (Beinschiene) = 97% confident :rolleyes: :rolleyes: you counted plosive onset on a 64kbps MP3 and called it science :dumb: :dumbbravo: lyrik this is the same energy as the tram braking hum analysis, you are a germanist not an audio engineer :banghead: :banghead:

47 swans. zero photocopied chapters. i know which evidence chain i trust. :moonwalk:
ScribeOfTheGrid
Inner Circle
★★★★★
147witnessCord Or Bust EuclidWaveformOrBust
Posts: 1631
Reputation: -1 ■
Joined: Jul 17, 2006
From: Row 42, Column 9
LyrikUebersetzer wrote:the audio has a very slight Ohio A shift that makes the vowel ambiguous, but the plosive onset on the /g/ is shorter than a typical fricative-adjacent production


^ this. If it's "greave" then the column K thermal offset at row 47 maps to the armor metaphor through the same 0x47 coordinate that EuroTrash keeps mocking without ever citing a single cell reference of his own :P The WAV request is the only honest ask in this thread.

COLUMN K OR GTFO -- COUNTIF trade still open Grammar_Vigil -- rustypod resolves to 0x2F, check your XOR
LyrikUebersetzer
Inner Circle
★★★★★
Cheese Receipt TruthTomorrowMeansNeverDoubleZeroPusher47 Hatch Lines
Posts: 1705
Reputation: +20 ■■■
Joined: Jun 20, 2006
From: München, Germany (exchange student @ Ohio State)
EuroTrash_Herr666 called it "the same energy as the tram braking hum analysis" which I take as a compliment actually :D because the tram braking hum analysis was METHODOLOGICALLY SOUND and I still have the FFT printouts in my dorm room if anyone wants to see them. The difference between 64kbps MP3 and raw WAV is exactly the difference between reading a lyric translation and hearing Gabriel's own glottal onset - the compression literally clips the transient I am analyzing. If the forum wants to fund a copy of the raw interview file from the FaceCulture archive I will do the spectrographic work for free and post the annotated waveform here with the /g/ onset marked at sample resolution. Bitte, stop calling my methodology "the same energy" as things you cannot disprove and start asking why nobody else has checked the vowel trapezoid on Gabriel's Ohio A shift. The greave reading transforms the entire armor metaphor and nobody wants to sit with that because it means the song is even DARKER than the grief reading allowed. A man putting on greaves is not weeping - he is arming for something he knows will wound him. That is a different theology entirely.

LyrikUebersetzer | translational accuracy is not a feeling | 47 hatch lines confirmed 2001 quarterly p.47 | DAS BLATT IST ECHT, DIE ZAHLEN SIND SPUREN
krova_pl
Devoted
★★★★
147witness
Posts: 413
Reputation: +7 ■
Joined: Aug 08, 2006
From: warsaw, poland (but dreaming of texas)
LyrikUebersetzer wrote:If it is "greave," then the whole armor imagery in verse three becomes a single coherent metaphor
i think youre overcomplicating it. where is the proof

gabriel chantayan is the only american i trust