Board index » Third conditional in the moors

Grammar_Vigil
Devoted
★★★★
Frame Boundary Error47 Clock KnotsTomorrowMeansNeverFeed Server Timezone Witness
Posts: 445
Reputation: +6 ■
Joined: Aug 25, 2006
AIM: gr4mm4rV
From: Warsaw, Poland
My English homework today concerned third conditional clauses, the kind that separate those who have actually read a book from those who rely on predictive text. The exercises were, to put it mildly, elementary. I finished them in the time it took my mother to boil water for tea.

Afterwards, I reread the opening of *Wuthering Heights*. Brontë deploys the third conditional with surgical precision: "It would *have* been..." Not "would of," not "would have *did*," but the correct subjunctive form, used to convey a world that exists only in counterfactual regret. It is, I think, the literary equivalent of a perfectly constructed clockwork mechanism: every gear meshes, every clause resolves exactly where it must.

If the student who sits behind me in English class could spell "their" correctly for one consecutive week, I would consider the education system partially redeemed. But the conditional, alas, is not third-person singular. It is a ghost of a possibility that never was.

-- GV

"I aint read the notebook YET" -- GraceWarrior_77, day 102 of tomorrow. The book has 11 chapters. -- GV